For a one-page demonstration summary, score the result, its evidence and the next step separately. On the evidence row, use a description both reviewers can identify.

Name the difference between adjacent levels

Complete means the result has a source and date. Partial means a result is stated but either the source or date is missing. Missing means no result is stated. Use a separate criterion if you also need to judge the source’s strength.

Each score level has one observable rule for the evidence criterion.

Illustrated rubric for a one-page demonstration summary.

Score one borderline example independently

Try a summary with a result and source but no date. Compare the score and the reason each reviewer gives. Agree whether a date in an appendix qualifies before using the rubric on new submissions.

Two reviewers compare a borderline sample with a result and source but no date.

Illustrated calibration. Both should use the same definition.

Carnegie Mellon University guidance on rubrics