The pilot summary says “bookings rose.” The workbook covers only morning slots. Give the reviewer a claim they can check and a locator that takes them straight to the underlying counts.

Use a separate line for the evidence. In this fictional example, the before-and-after totals are both 60 available slots.

- Claim: Morning slot bookings rose from 18 of 60 to 23 of 60.
- Evidence: pilot-r3.xlsx, Morning tab, rows 8–9.
- Scope: mornings only, using the two periods shown in the table.

An example review note ties 18 of 60 and 23 of 60 to the Morning tab and a dated workbook revision.

Example evidence line. Give the denominator and exact location.

Check what the evidence actually supports

Open the named revision and read both numerators and denominators. Confirm the rows refer to comparable periods. That supports a change from 30.0% to about 38.3% in the recorded morning slots. It leaves the afternoon and the cause of the change open.

A margin note highlights the scope limit: morning slots only, with no causal conclusion.

Example wording check. Keep the claim within the source’s scope.

If the source moves, update the locator along with the wording. Keep measured results and proposed explanations on separate lines so later reviewers can trace each one.